The SCIgen website is one that creates science based
research papers instantly. With the click of a button, any student can have a
seemingly intellectual, scholarly research paper. Key word in the last sentence
being “seemingly”. Each paper generated, appears to be knowledgeable and well
constructed, until one takes a deeper look at the paper. First, each of the
research papers included a rather long title, hinting that the paper is about
something complex. For example, some of the titles were “Towards the
Understanding of Lambda Calculus that Made Exploring and Possibly Improving
Courseware a Reality” and “Constant-Time, Ubiquitous Configurations for Linked
Lists.” More conventions I noticed was the use of advanced vocabulary and very
clearly labeled titles and subtitles. Words such as “ambimorphic”, “heuristic”, and “ubiquitous”
lead readers to believe that the author is intelligent, therefore readers may
be impressed, rather than fooled. The structure of each paper, specifically the
titles and subtitles show that the paper is well organized and put together in
an intricate manner. Next, I observed the use of graphs and visual displays.
Each paper that I explored had multiple visuals included within them which makes
the reader think that the author is very involved and interactive in his work.
Lastly, the convention that I believe has the biggest impact with convincing
readers that these papers are real/factually correct, is the use of in text
citations and the references. Each paper had a very long list of references and
used numerous in text citations. All of these conventions make each SCIgen
created research paper appear credible and logical, although none of it may in
fact be true.
While clicking through multiple comics on the pandyland
website, I noticed that I struggled a bit with finding conventions. Because it
was not a piece of writing, I was forced to think of more “outside the box” conventions.
Because comics are limited to pictures and small text boxes, I noticed most of
the actions are expressed through facial expression and the type of text box
used. Each box in the comic strip has vivid facial expressions to help
emphasize what cannot be said in the small text box. Along with that, the type
of text box being used also helps to accentuate the emotion of the characters.
Although most of the text boxes are regular circle/oval shaped, I noticed a
jagged circle looking thing was used to convey shouting or yelling. Also, the
texts themselves tended to be short and simple, which I think broadens the audience.
A more obvious convention includes animations, usually consisting of the two
men and a simple action.
The last site, memegenerator, does exactly what you’d think
it does, which is generate memes. These often include a popular picture or
cartoon, along with a funny, creative caption or pun. The captions are short
and easy to read, attracting as many readers as possible. These are usually
intended to create laughter and humor.
Although I’m not sure if this ties in, a website I found was
http://passwordsgenerator.net. I don’t
entirely understand if “passwords” are a genre, but I did notice that there are
more conventions to them then you’d think. For example, many passwords must
include over 8 characters, use an upper and lowercase letter, include a symbol,
and include a number.
While exploring the different genre generator websites, I noticed
many interesting things. Each different website had a similar concept, yet was
so different in its content. While the SCIgen website constructed random
research papers, the pandyland website created short comics, and the
memgenerator created several different memes. One thing looking at these websites
made me realize, was the relationship between genres and their audience. Each
genre has a different intended audience. For example, the audience of a
research paper would be a teacher or professor, where the audience of a comic
or a meme would be more broad, expanding to kids, teens, or really anyone
looking for a laugh. Because each website followed a different format and
consisted of different context, they helped me see genres from multiple
perspectives, all which helped better my understanding of genre.
Your analysis over the three given genres in terms of their formats, languages, and purposes is detailed with specific examples for support. In your conclusion, you make a great point that due to the fact that different genres have different intended audience, genres must be different from each other in some ways, such as the tone of the words. A meme is more casual and humorous than a research paper for sure. I also visited the Secure Password Generator you introduced in your writing. It is a interesting website and sometimes we may find it very handy in our lives.
ReplyDeleteJessica,
ReplyDeleteI really liked how you mentioned that "Words such as “ambimorphic”, “heuristic”, and “ubiquitous” lead readers to believe that the author is intelligent, therefore readers may be impressed, rather than fooled." Since this kind of language is not familiar to us, we simply believe what we are reading because we don't necessarily have enough understanding to say it's wrong. I feel like this is something we encounter every day with advertisements, politicians, etc. I also like how you noted that the citations in the paper make it seem even more legitimate. I think you did a really good job of identifying how certain conventions of a computer science research paper makes it seem more credible, which is their desired intention.
J-Rey,
ReplyDeleteAfter reading through your PB1B I can confidently say that you had one an extremely thorough analysis of the genres created by the genre generator websites, in particular the CS paper generator. One thing that I really liked about your assignment was what Piper pointed out (with mentioning large and scientific sounding words in order to sound legitimate and impressive), which was that you included examples to back up points. The password generator you found was also of interest to me, as while it is not something I would come up with on my own as a genre, as you pointed out it does seem to have many of its own conventions. Some website passwords may even need to be more specific (i.e. cannot include any dictionary word), so the conventions may extend even beyond those generally associated with the genre.